Trackum

Retargeting and remarketing: how it works with consent

Retargeting shows ads to people who have already been on your site. Here is how lists arise, why consent makes them smaller and how to check the real benefit.

Guide · · 4 min read · Written with AI, AI-assisted review on

Retargeting and remarketing: how it works with consent
📷 Bruno Kelzer · Unsplash

What is retargeting (remarketing)?

Retargeting, also called remarketing, means showing ads specifically to people who have already been on your website or in your app, or who have given you their contact details. Instead of addressing strangers, you remind interested people of a product, an offer or an enquiry. Google describes this as reaching people again who previously interacted with your offer, and now calls the lists in Google Ads your data segments. On Meta they are called Custom Audiences.

The difference from ordinary advertising is the source of the audience: it comes from your own data. That can make retargeting cheaper per result, because the people already know you, but it does not have to (see the section on deadweight further down). It also means that the quality of your data and your consents sets the limit.

How do audience lists arise in Google Ads and Meta?

In Google Ads, data segments arise from visitors recognised by the Google tag or Google Analytics, from contact details you upload as Customer Match, and from people who submitted your lead form. Google also adds Engaged Audiences automatically, meaning users who took action on your website. On Meta you build Custom Audiences from the Meta Pixel, from customer lists and from interactions with your Pages.

  • All website visitors in the last few days
  • Visitors to particular pages, such as prices or products
  • People with a product in the basket who did not buy
  • Customers from an uploaded contact list
  • People who submitted a form

Every list needs members before it can serve ads. How large it has to be depends on the platform and changes. Read the Help of the platform in question rather than relying on a figure from an article.

→ Cookie banner with Consent Mode v2: compliant, with no monthly licence

For retargeting, information is stored on or read from the device. In Germany this is governed by § 25 TDDDG, which generally requires visitors’ consent. In its Help on conversion measurement, Google writes that you should switch off the collection of remarketing data if you do not have the consent required by law or Google policy for a user, and that advertisers in the EEA should set up Google Consent Mode correctly. This article is not legal advice.

The consequence: only the share of visitors who agree in the cookie banner ends up in the list. An example with assumed values: of 10,000 visitors a month, 4,000 agree. Only these 4,000 can go into retargeting lists, and of those you still lose the ones who return with a different browser or device. A small list is therefore normal. Anyone who tries to enlarge it artificially by bypassing the banner or hiding the Reject option risks trouble instead of reach.

Which audiences and exclusions make sense?

Start with a few lists that each have a clear reason, and always exclude the group that has already completed the step. Someone who has just bought does not need an ad for the same product.

  • Check consent and measurement: the Google tag or the Meta Pixel may only collect data after consent, and the events (page view, basket, purchase, enquiry) must arrive.
  • Create a list with a clear reason, for example “basket without purchase” or “visited the pricing page”.
  • Exclude the group that has already completed the step, such as buyers or people who have submitted an enquiry.
  • Set the membership duration and frequency, design an ad with a clear next step and only evaluate it after a few weeks.
Simple retargeting audiences and matching exclusions
AudienceWhat it signalsExclude
Viewed a productInterest, no decision yetBuyers of the last few weeks
Basket without purchaseIntent to buy, step still openBuyers, visitors to the order confirmation
Visited the pricing or contact pageEnquiry closePeople who have submitted an enquiry
Existing customersTrust in placeCustomers with a current job

→ Setting up Google Consent Mode v2 correctly: no warning in Tag Assistant

How often may the same ad appear?

Too much retargeting is annoying. Set a membership duration, meaning how long someone stays on the list, that fits your buying cycle: short for impulse purchases, longer for enquiries with a decision process. Cap the frequency where the platform offers it, and change the ad instead of showing the same one for ever. Check regularly whether rising frequency still leads to rising results.

How do you measure real incremental benefit instead of deadweight?

Many visitors buy even without an ad. Retargeting is then credited with conversions that would have happened anyway. This is called the deadweight effect. To see the real incremental benefit, you split a list randomly into two halves. One gets the ad, the other does not. Then you compare the purchase rate of the two groups.

An example with assumed values: the group with the ad is 1,000 people with 40 purchases. The group without the ad is 1,000 people with 32 purchases. The incremental benefit is 8 purchases, not 40. Divide the ad spend by 8 and you know the cost per additional purchase. Some platforms also offer such tests as a feature of their own.

No retargeting evaluation without clean measurement

The test calculation only works if enquiries and purchases are counted reliably and Consent Mode passes consent on to Google and Meta. Trackum sets up this measurement in Google Tag Manager and tests it with and without consent before anything goes live.

Frequently asked questions

Is retargeting the same as remarketing?

In practice, both terms usually mean the same thing: advertising to people who have already had contact with your offer. Google spoke of remarketing for a long time, and in Google Ads the lists are now called your data segments.

Do I need consent for retargeting?

For setting cookies or reading information on the device, § 25 TDDDG generally requires consent. Google also points out that you should switch off data collection for remarketing for users without consent. This article is not legal advice.

Why is my retargeting list so small?

Only visitors who agreed in the cookie banner may go into the list. On top of that come visitors with ad blockers and those who return on another device. A small list is therefore normal and not a fault in the account.

How often should visitors see the same retargeting ad?

There is no universally valid number. Watch the frequency per person and the response to it: if frequency keeps rising while clicks and enquiries stagnate, the same ad is being shown too often and you should cap it or change it.

Sources

  1. Google Ads Help: Your data segments (remarketing) support.google.com
  2. Google Ads Help: Conversion measurement support.google.com
  3. Meta Help: Custom Audiences facebook.com
  4. § 25 TDDDG, gesetze-im-internet.de gesetze-im-internet.de
Help