Trackum

Advertising agency or digital agency: what small firms need

Traditional advertising agency, digital marketing agency or specialist: who takes on which task, how the costs differ and which warning signs to look for.

Guide · · 4 min read · Written with AI, AI-assisted review on

Advertising agency or digital agency: what small firms need
📷 Faizur Rehman · Unsplash

A traditional advertising agency mostly looks after brand, design and campaign ideas, a digital marketing agency measurable digital channels such as search advertising, social media and SEO. For small firms that mainly want more enquiries, a specialist for exactly that channel is often the right fit. A full-service advertising agency is worthwhile when brand, print, website and online channels are meant to work together from a single source. This article shows the differences, assigns tasks to the suitable partner and names warning signs.

What is the difference between an advertising agency and a digital agency?

The difference lies in the focus. An advertising agency develops the look and the message: name, logo, colours, ad creatives, brochures, posters, often photos and videos too. Its success is harder to measure, because awareness and image grow slowly. A digital agency, also called a digital marketing agency, works with channels that can be measured and steers campaigns by clicks, enquiries and sales.

The boundaries blur. Many advertising agencies have a digital department, and many digital agencies also design ad creatives and websites. More important than the label is where the team has the most experience and who actually does the work in the end.

What does a full-service advertising agency mean?

A full-service advertising agency offers strategy, design, production and placement from a single source, so for example concept, logo, website, photos, ads and management of the online channels. The advantage is one contact and a consistent look. Possible disadvantages: some services are partly handed to partners or freelancers, and the team is not equally strong in every discipline. So ask in the meeting who delivers which service themselves and what is bought in.

→ Cookie banner with Consent Mode v2: compliant, with no monthly licence

Which partner suits which task?

Task and suitable partner
TaskSuitable partnerWhat to look out for
Name, logo, brand identityAdvertising agency or designerClarify the usage rights to the designs
Print advertising, trade fairs, postersAdvertising agencyPrint-ready files and a clear approval process
Enquiries through Google AdsDigital agency or search advertising specialistAccount in your name, reports based on enquiries rather than clicks
Being found better in GoogleSEO specialist or digital agencyNo ranking guarantee, traceable measures
Social media managementSocial media agency or freelancerWho creates the content, how often, with what aim
WebsiteWeb agency or digital agencyWho maintains it afterwards, who owns the access
Measuring enquiries and salesTracking specialist or digital agencyTest with and without consent, documentation

The table shows that an agency does not have to be able to do everything. Anyone who hires several specialists does, however, need someone to hold the parts together, and that is usually you. It costs time but gives you more control over each individual service.

How do the costs of an advertising agency and a digital agency differ?

Concrete prices depend heavily on scope and provider, so this article names no sums. The cost logic can be compared, though. Advertising agencies often bill projects, for example concept, design and production as a package. Digital agencies often charge a monthly fee for ongoing management, as a flat fee, by the hour or as a share of the ad budget. With paid advertising the ad budget itself comes on top, and it goes to the platform and not to the agency.

A larger set-up with project management, consulting and several specialists can mean higher hourly rates, but it brings coordination and experience. A specialist is often leaner and takes on only their part. So do not compare quotes by hourly rate but by result: what is agreed, which reports do you get and how long are you tied in?

Billing methods compared
BillingTypical forWhat to look out for
Project feeLogo, website, brochure, conceptWhat is included, how many rounds of corrections there are, who owns the usage rights
Monthly flat feeOngoing management of a channelExact scope of services, reports, notice period
Hourly rateConsulting, analyses, small tasksAgree an hours estimate or a cap in advance
Share of the ad budgetManagement of paid advertisingMore budget means more fee. So set a cap and a goal, such as cost per enquiry

→ Setting up Google Consent Mode v2 correctly: no warning in Tag Assistant

What do small firms really need?

Small firms first need what brings enquiries, and only after that the big brand presence. An example: a painting and decorating firm with five employees has a logo and a simple website and wants more enquiries from its own town. It does not need a brand concept. It needs a complete Google Business Profile, a website with a clear way to get in touch, reviews and perhaps search ads for its main services. A specialist or a small digital agency that also sets up measurement is enough for that.

It looks different for a company that is just starting out, needs a name and a presence, is planning packaging and print material and wants to run several channels at the same time. Here a full-service agency saves coordination. In both cases the rule is: decide beforehand how you will measure success.

How do you decide with four questions?

With four questions you place your project before you ask for quotes. Answer them in writing, and then you can give every agency the same brief.

  • Is something meant to come about that you can look at or print, such as a logo, a prospectus or a trade fair stand? Then you need design and production: an advertising agency or designer.
  • Is your goal a number you can read off every week, such as enquiries or orders? Then measurability comes first: a digital agency or a specialist for the channel.
  • How much time do you have to coordinate several service providers? Little time points to a fixed contact, plenty of time to individual specialists.
  • What should happen after the assignment? For a completed project such as a logo or website, you need no ongoing management. For channels that are managed permanently, compare monthly fee, reports and notice period.

Which warning signs are there with agencies?

  • Guarantees of first place in Google or of a particular number of enquiries.
  • The ad account or the access sits with the agency, and you get no access.
  • Reports show only clicks, reach and impressions, but no enquiries or sales.
  • A long minimum term with no way out before first results are visible.
  • Unsolicited emails or calls saying your website is “not listed”. Google explicitly names such messages as a reason for scepticism.
  • No questions about your business, but a standard package for everyone.

Independent measurement helps against most warning signs. If your enquiries and sales are counted cleanly, you can judge any agency by results. Trackum sets up the tracking for this in your firm’s Google Tag Manager, and the free check shows beforehand whether your website already measures correctly.

Frequently asked questions

What does an advertising agency cost?

There is no flat answer, because scope, team size and service vary widely. Projects such as a logo or website are usually billed as a package, ongoing management as a monthly fee or by the hour. Get several quotes for the same scope and ask about the total cost.

When is a full-service advertising agency worthwhile?

It is worthwhile when several things are meant to come about at once, such as brand, website, print material and online channels, and you want one contact for everything. For a clearly defined goal such as more enquiries through Google Ads, a specialist is often enough.

Can I combine an advertising agency and a digital agency?

Yes, that is common. Decide beforehand who is responsible for what, who owns access and files, and how results are measured. Shared measurement that both sides use avoids arguments over numbers.

Do I need an agency at all as a small business?

Not necessarily. Google writes in its Help that small local businesses can probably do most of the SEO work themselves. An agency mainly pays off if you lack time or expertise, or if a website rebuild is coming up.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO expert? developers.google.com
  2. Google Ads Help: Manage access to your Google Ads account support.google.com
  3. Google Business Profile Help: Add or claim your Business Profile support.google.com
Help